As several companies put forward proposals to build AI infrastructure in space, experts warn it would have major drawbacks on the night sky, especially in Canada. The proposals filed with the United States Federal Communications Commission (FCC) by major players like SpaceX, BlueOrigin and others surround what are known as “Orbital Data Centres.” A Regina-based astronomer and researcher is among those warning about what the arrays, which propose thousands or even hundreds of thousands more satellites going into orbit, would make satellites inescapable for both casual and scientific observers on the ground. “We’ve been able to make some predictions for what this would look like in the sky,” said Samantha Lawler, an associate professor of astronomy at the University of Regina. The predictions envision a night sky where satellites outnumber visible stars. “Where we are, in the southern part of Canada, this would just pass over head and you’d see it for a couple hours right around sunrise and sunset,” Lawler said. “In far northern Canada, you would actually kind of see this ring rotating over your head all night during the winter months,” Lawler said, adding that most current satellites don’t fly over those areas, meaning it would be a new effect for otherwise dark skies in the north. Laurie Rousseau-Nepton, an assistant professor of Astronomy and Astrophysics at the University of Toronto, said the dark sky is a resource for the north – and needs to be protected as such. “That is part of the culture, part of the beauty of the land,” Rousseau-Nepton said. “It would be heartbreaking just to think that we would not have access to the sky, that we’ve always had access, and that our ancestors had access, and that I think and truly believe next generations should also have access to.” Rousseau-Nepton is also the first Indigenous woman in Canada to earn a PhD in astrophysics. “We’ve all wondered by looking at it, I developed my own interest in astronomy by looking at it. What’s going to happen if we don’t have this?” Rousseau-Nepton said. Despite the global impact of the decisions, the authority largely lies with the countries where the satellites will launch from. “All these companies have to get permission from is a U.S. federal agency,” Lawler said. Canada needs larger role in ‘politics of space’: senatorSenator Paula Simons, who first became involved in emerging space-related issues thanks to conversations with Lawler over space debris landing in Saskatchewan, said that many of the laws and regulations surrounding space date back to the U.S./Soviet space race. “We need an international conversation, that maybe Canada needs to step up and help lead, about how we manage space, which does not belong to the United States of America,” Simons said. “It is the shared legacy of the entire world.” Simons added because American and Chinese companies are dominating the current era of the space race, Cold War-era policies are no longer cutting it. A senate inquiry into the issue of satellite debris falling to earth was launched by Simons in March, which she described as a jumping off point to a larger conversation. “Not just the question of things falling out of the sky, but things bumping into each other in space, which sounds absurd. There’s a lot of space,” Simons said. “But if you start putting a million satellites in orbit then [there’s a] real risk of it.” The senator’s concerns go further than the possibility of a million satellites in orbit for a SpaceX data centre in space – a proposition she called “unrealistic” – but also for other possible projects like a space mirror to deflect daylight. She’s hopeful that future legislation can ban concepts like space advertising and daylight mirror projects from being launched in Canada as the country works to build up its sovereign launch capacity. “What Canada can do to have an impact on what China and the United States do is a little bit harder to say,” Simons said. “Canada is a big power in space relative to its size and the size of its economy. We have a long legacy of satellite technology. We’ve had astronauts in space in a way that no other country with our population has been able to, but we are still small players when it comes to the politics of space.” Simons said she fears space pollution and satellite congestion will not be top-of-mind issues for many – especially in the United States. She cautioned about the possible effects. “If we don’t get out ahead of this, we’re going to suffer for it potentially for generations to come,” Simons noted. Orbital overloadAs the amount of satellites and other space junk rises, Lawler worries about a phenomenon known as “Kessler Syndrome.” According to NASA, Kessler Syndrome is caused by space debris creating a chain reaction of collisions and even more debris to the point that Earth’s orbit is no longer usable. With more satellites in the sky, orbital data centres or otherwise, Lawler cautions what that could mean for the future of space access. “We’re already in Kessler Syndrome at many altitudes and we’re launching more. When I watched the Artemis II launch, a few months ago, I noticed that there were these cutouts in the launch timing,” Lawler said. “That’s when satellites are flying overhead.” Lawler said major operators like Starlink already avoid collisions every 75 seconds. “They have to maneuver faster and faster, and they think they can do this with a million satellites,” she said. “There’s been some research that shows that they actually can’t maneuver enough to have that many satellites in orbit.” Lawler said that losing access to orbit would be catastrophic given how dependent modern communications, weather, navigation and even other uses like banking systems are dependent on satellites. “If we put too many satellites into orbit and we start having collisions, this is a very real danger that I don’t think very many governments are taking seriously,” Lawler said. SpaceX’s FCC filing mentions a project of this scale and ambition would put humanity a step closer to becoming a “Kardashev II-level civilization” by better harnessing the power of the sun. Elon Musk promotes the same ideology in a video posted on SpaceX’s web page for A.I. Satellites – branded “StarMind.” However, Lawler cautions a project intended to advance humanity – could actually keep people grounded.
|